Even being 2,000 miles removed from the situation when the uproar around Sunshine Village began this last winter, I felt like it was happening just down the road thanks to one thing: social media. Voices from both sides wanted to be heard and smack dab in the middle of this blizzard of opinion was Doug Firby, the communications and marketing guy for Sunshine Village. Now, I have no idea who is right and who is wrong, that is not what this post is about. What’s done is done, people have their opinions. What I wanted to know was what Doug had learned from all that had happened and what he hoped to do moving forward.
Let me say that I really appreciate the time Doug put toward these answers. You can tell these aren’t the canned sound-bites I sometimes see in interviews, these are genuine. If I were you I’d drop everything and take some notes. Really. This is good stuff.
SlopeFillers: Doug, tell us a little bit about yourself and your marketing background.
Doug: I am relatively new to marketing. I came to the Communications position at Sunshine Village in July 2008, after working in newspapers on the editorial side for more than 30 years. Except for a few months in Marketing in the 1990s, all that time was editorial. Since I’ve taken on this position, I’ve taken a couple of university level courses in Marketing to provide some additional academic perspective.
Historically, people who work in the news media have adapted very well to Communications jobs. They understand what journalists need, and are able to anticipate those needs well and cater to them.
SlopeFillers: Social media is a tricky space to master these days. What lessons have you learned about social media this last winter that you’ll apply with Sunshine Village’s profiles going forward?
Doug: My strength has been in traditional media, but I have always had an assistant working in social media during my time at Sunshine. What we learned is that it’s not enough to “dabble” in Facebook, Twitter and other popular social media sites. Posting updates when there is “happy” news, like large dumps of snow, is easy. It’s much more challenging to deal with an angry mob that has heard a narrative that puts your organization in a bad light. Really, it means you have to take social media seriously, and not treat it like it’s some sort of passing fad. Social media is where people have their conversations, and you need to be part of any conversation that involves your organization.
The key things I’ve learned are these:
Finally, I think any organization needs to fully consider the communications or public relations implications of any major action they decide to take. That means having those PR professionals involved in the decision-making process. The company’s decision might ultimately be the same, but even so it will be made with eyes wide open.
SlopeFillers: That is an interesting idea to route negative discussion elsewhere, like your blog. Who did you have monitoring/responding to comments on the blog? And along with that, did you have a policy in place to guide how they responded or did each response need to be approved?
Doug: We have a very small communications team sharing the duties of monitoring and responding – myself, my assistant and one other. Our guidelines are to stick to the facts, be respectful in replies and try not to get drawn into debates. Responses don’t need to be pre-authorized, but everyone has a good sense of when to seek advice if a question appears to be excessively hostile or leading into a broader discussion. The objective is to bend over backwards to keep the lines of communication open, and to allow people to have their say, regardless of whether we agree or disagree. The only comments that aren’t approved are ones that contain obscenities, attack the character of others or that deliberately misrepresent the situation as we know it. It’s always a judgment call, but we try to err on the side of being very tolerant.
SlopeFillers: For a while there it appeared the Sunshine Village Facebook page was missing. What was the tipping point that made you decide to pull it down, when did you decide it was time to bring it back, and what are some of your goals going forward?
Doug: The Facebook page was closed down for a time when it was being swamped with negativity – constant swearing, highly abusive language, and there were several angry participants who were using it as a means to conduct a kind of a kangaroo court. Several questioners were trying to “cross-exam” Sunshine (i.e. demand answers and then challenge the veracity of those answers) on the Facebook page. It had a bit of a mob feel to it. Individuals who tried to defend Sunshine were shouted down and ridiculed. Others who just wanted to post images or a video of a great day on the slopes were equally singled out. So, all in all, it seemed to have descended into a very unhealthy “discussion”, if you could even call it that.
We thought long and hard about taking it down, because we really didn’t want to. The conventional wisdom is that you’re supposed to just let the negative criticism run its course. Ultimately, we decided we had no choice but to take a break, though. Before we put it back up, we made sure we had the resources to moderate the discussions on the page, so that we wouldn’t just fall back into another round of negativity. That’s partly why we created the blog: “If you want to carry on with a discussion about the fired staff, here’s the place to do it.” This allowed people who wanted to resume normal communications – to talk about the snow or events or whatever – to do so on Facebook. The page was down for several weeks: Enough time had passed that a lot of people didn’t want to continue on with the endless discussion about the dismissals anyway; a lot of them were tired of the subject by then.
Going forward, our Facebook page is becoming what it always should have been – not so much a pure promotional tool as a place to have conversations, to share a sense of community and to provide information about upcoming events. There are still some critical comments on the page, and we listen to those comments and channel them to the appropriate managers. That’s part of what any Facebook page should be doing. Our page is now part of a much larger communications vision, employing all of the conventional and social media.
SlopeFillers: Anything else you’d like to add? Advice? Other lessons? Ideas?
Doug: I’ve learned not to be too closely tied to “conventional wisdom” on social media, because this environment is so new I don’t think anyone fully understands it. Do what feels right in your gut, have a very clear sense of your principles and stick to them.
Most importantly, do NOT wait until you are in a crisis to deal with the communications challenges. I hope some of your readers can use our experience as a cautionary tale. Take our story, show it to your bosses and tell them, “If you’re not prepared, this could happen to you.” Have a crisis communications plan in place. Be willing to invest in the time and resources you need to do social media properly. Educate yourself on the basic ground rules, and immerse yourself in social media until you fully understand them. Spend a lot of time listening. None of these actions will prevent a negative round of publicity, but they might help your organization stay in the conversation.
Realize that a communications revolution has taken place. This is how people talk today. Don’t treat social media like it’s a passing fad.
One final thought: Once you understand social media, you’ll see how effective they can be in connecting you with your audience in ways you never could before. You’ll learn a lot from those people about how you can run your organization better. You’ll learn about what people want. It’s time extremely well-invested.
New stories, ideas, and jobs delivered to your inbox every Friday morning.